Skip to main content
Curved deck towards the house

Guide

Timber or composite decking?

The real differences are upkeep, look, heat and cost. A stained pine deck and a composite deck of ours show them.

By Timbaland Carpentry · Updated

Curved deck towards the house, North Ryde

  • NSW contractor licence276621CCarpenter, held since 2014Check the register
  • QuotesFree, on siteMonday to Saturday, from 7am
  • Registered business65 193 408 542Timbaland CarpentryCheck the ABN
In this guide · 8 sections

Choose timber if you want the look, feel and smell of real wood and don’t mind oiling or staining it every so often. Choose composite if you would rather wash a deck than recoat it, and you’re happy to pay more for the boards to get that.

Both can make a good Sydney deck when the frame underneath is built properly. The real differences are upkeep, look, heat and cost, and two of our own decks show them well. For composite options in detail, see our composite decking page.

What is the real difference between timber and composite?

Timber is a natural material. Every board has its own grain and colour, it can be sanded and recoated, and it changes as it ages. Composite is a manufactured board made from wood fibre and plastic, usually with a tougher outer layer. It comes in a fixed colour and pattern, it doesn’t take oil and it can’t be sanded back.

Underneath, both sit on a frame of bearers and joists. The boards are only part of the job: the frame, footings, stairs and balustrades are much the same work whichever board you choose.

What does a timber deck need to stay looking good?

Timber needs a coat of oil or stain every so often to keep its colour and protect the surface. Left alone, most decking timber weathers to a silver-grey, and the surface can develop fine cracks. Some people like that grey look; others want the original colour back, which means cleaning and recoating.

Our deck in Monterey shows what a finish does for timber. It is a treated pine deck under a pergola, and our photos show it before and after the boards were stained a merbau colour. The stain turned plain pine into a deck with a much warmer, darker tone. The catch is that a stained deck needs that coat renewed as it wears, especially where feet and furniture rub it.

Before: bare treated pine
Treated pine deck before staining, under black steel pergola with clear roof, Monterey See the job →
After: merbau-colour stain
Treated pine deck after a merbau-tone stain, glossy finish, Monterey See the job →

Hardwoods such as merbau, spotted gum and blackbutt hold up better than pine and look good oiled or left to grey. They still need the same kind of care if you want to keep their colour.

What does composite give you that timber doesn’t?

The main gain is upkeep. Composite doesn’t need oiling, staining or sanding, and a wash now and then keeps it clean. The colour is even across the deck, and the boards don’t splinter, which matters around pools and for children.

Our curved deck in North Ryde is built from composite. The yard drops away from the house, so the deck steps across two levels, and it curves around existing trees. Because it is composite, it keeps its colour without a weekend of oiling each year. Composite also suits wet areas: in Dundas, an in-ground spa is set into a grey composite deck, and in Bellevue Hill a curved composite deck sits beside the pool.

Deck towards the house in afternoon light, North Ryde See the job →
Grey composite deck with in-ground spa set into deck, steps to house, Dundas See the job →

Where does composite fall short?

Composite isn’t the right answer for everyone:

  • Feel and look. Even good composite boards look and feel more uniform than timber. If you love natural grain and variation, timber will suit you better.
  • Heat. Dark composite boards can get very hot in full summer sun. Lighter colours help, and so does shade.
  • Movement. Composite boards grow and shrink in length with temperature, so they need set gaps at the ends and edges, as the manufacturer specifies.
  • Repairs. A deep scratch or burn in timber can be sanded out. In composite, the usual fix is a new board, so it helps to keep a few spares.
  • Cost. Composite boards usually cost more to buy than timber, and the frame may need more joists to meet the manufacturer’s spacing.

Which costs more over the life of the deck?

Composite usually costs more on the day it’s built. Timber usually costs more to keep looking the same, because of cleaning and recoating over the years.

How those balance out depends on the size of the deck, how much sun it gets, which timber you would choose and whether you would oil it yourself or pay someone. A small, shaded deck you’re happy to oil yourself favours timber. A large deck in full sun that you never want to recoat favours composite. Our deck cost guide explains what else changes the price.

What about warranties?

Composite boards and many decking products come with a manufacturer’s warranty, and the terms vary a lot between brands and product lines. Check the manufacturer’s warranty terms for the exact board you’re considering: what it covers (such as fading, staining or structural failure), for how long, and what it asks of the installer and the owner.

Most product warranties depend on the boards being installed to the manufacturer’s instructions, including joist spacing, gaps and fixings. A board warranty covers the boards, not the frame or the workmanship, so ask your builder how they set out the frame and follow those instructions.

Can you mix timber and composite?

Yes, and it often works well. A deck can have composite boards with a timber pergola or screen, or a hardwood deck with composite steps in a high-wear spot. At Lane Cove West, a merbau deck sits under a timber pergola. In Birchgrove, composite runs across a balcony, an external stair and a rooftop bench, with a composite privacy screen. Matching colours across materials takes some care, so look at samples side by side.

So which should you choose?

Choose timber if you value natural grain and feel, want the option to sand and refinish, prefer a lower upfront cost and don’t mind recoating. Choose composite if you want low upkeep, an even colour, no splinters around a pool or spa and are happy to pay more at the start.

If you’re still deciding, our decking materials guide compares treated pine, the hardwoods and composite in more detail. When you’re ready to price both, see our composite decking and timber decking pages, and send us photos of the space.

Also check the builder’s licence on the NSW Government licence register. Timbaland Carpentry holds NSW Contractor Licence 276621C in the Carpenter class.

Planning a deck? Tell us about it

Typical prices are a planning guide; we measure your space and give you a written quote.

Quotes
Free, on site
Licensed
Since 2014

Free quote

Get your free on-site quote

Send the details below and we'll call you back to book a time to see the job.